Getting a second opinion before pet surgery

Nearly half the people who write to us start with a version of the same sentence: I do not want to offend my vet. Here is the thing every vet knows and most owners do not: second opinions are a normal, documented part of veterinary practice, supported in writing by the profession itself.

EMReviewed by Eben Martin, Veterinary Surgeon · Updated August 2026 · 8 min read

When a second opinion is worth it

A second opinion earns its cost when the stakes are high and the answer is not obvious: a large quote, an uncertain or changed diagnosis, major surgery on an older animal, a recovery going off script, or a gut feeling that the plan does not fit the pet in front of you.

Not every diagnosis needs one. A routine desex does not. But when someone quotes you $7,000 for an operation you had not heard of a week ago, pausing for an expert second look is not distrust. It is what any surgeon would do for their own dog.

The Australian Veterinary Association has a written policy supporting referrals and second opinions, state veterinary boards expect vets to cooperate with them, and your clinic must provide your pet's clinical records on request. You do not need permission, a referral, or a diplomatic excuse. A simple "we are getting a second opinion before we decide" is professional, normal and complete.

What records to gather

Most clinics will email records the same day you ask. Our guide to getting your pet's records covers the exact words to use and your rights if a clinic drags its feet.

GP vet or surgeon?

A second GP opinion is a fine choice for everyday medicine. For surgery it has a structural problem: you are asking a generalist to referee a specialist question. If the decision on the table is an operation, the useful second opinion comes from someone who performs that operation and sees its failures as well as its successes. That is the entire reason this service exists.

What it should cost

An in person specialist consultation in Australia commonly costs $200 to $400 before any imaging. An online written opinion from us starts at $250, with the records reviewed and the reasoning in writing. Against a four figure operation, either is cheap. The expensive option is the wrong surgery, or the right surgery avoided for the wrong reasons.

A good second opinion does one of two things: it changes the plan, or it lets you go ahead with the original plan without the doubt. Both outcomes are worth paying for.

Common questions

Will my vet find out I got a second opinion?

Only if you tell them, or ask us to write something they can read, which we recommend: the opinion is built to be shared, and most treating vets receive them professionally. Vets seek second opinions from each other constantly.

What if I already consented to surgery and it is booked for Friday?

A booking is not a contract to proceed. Clinics reschedule surgeries every week. If new information matters, it matters more than a diary entry, and a same week opinion is exactly the kind of case we prioritise.

Can I get a second opinion after the surgery already happened?

Yes, and people do: to understand a complication, to check a recovery, or for peace of mind about a decision already made. Records tell the story either way.

Want a surgeon's eyes on your pet's case?

An independent written opinion, from $250.